Energythinking

No more new HVDC lines in Hesse - burying is underway in Bavaria....

12.06.2019

No more new HVDC lines in Hesse - burying is underway in Bavaria....

So has their massive resistance, which has been widely reported in the media in recent years, really borne fruit?

https://www.dgs.de/news/en-detail/280717-von-leitungen-kohlestrom-und-trassenluege/

Or is the end just a political distraction?

P44: The extra-high-voltage line was to run from Altenfeld in Thuringia via Würgau in Upper Franconia to Ludersheim in the south of Nuremberg. And now, rather unexpectedly, Bavaria's black-orange state government announced on Tuesday: "The construction of the P44 alternating current line or its variants P44mod are definitely off the table."

https://www.stromautobahn.de/widerstand-wirkt-bau-der-stromtrasse-p44-p44mod-gestoppt/

https://www.stmwi.bayern.de/presse/pressemitteilungen/pressemitteilung/pm/165-2019

The Franconian-Bavarian route opponents are nevertheless skeptical: "The campaign alliance against the south-east route will continue to keep an eye on the plans of the transmission system operators." However, they see it as "positive that the political resistance in some municipalities is proceeding in very good cooperation with the citizens. It was only in April that the alliance against the P44mod from Nürnberger Land to Coburg was reorganized, which certainly contributed to the decision to cancel the P44mod."

One day later, however, Federal Minister of Economics Peter Altmaier (CDU) emerges from obscurity and invites people to a press conference 45 minutes beforehand, for which registration is mandatory. There he says that "on my initiative, the states of Bavaria and Thuringia will be relieved ... without the construction of further power lines in Hesse".

https://www.bmwi.de/Redaktion/DE/Downloads/J-L/loesung-netzprobleme-dreilaendereck.pdf

There should obviously not even be a shred of doubt that the federal government is holding the reins on the grid expansion brakes: Altmaier is the master of the grids, is supposed to be the sign. And then there is a sentence in the press release that completely puts all the jubilation about success into perspective: The energy ministers "therefore ask the Federal Network Agency to examine the proposal outlined below and to consult publicly before specifying it in the network development plan". In other words: nothing is fixed.

And what are the Bavarian governments doing? They are neither fully committed to renewable energies nor are they abolishing the 10H wind distance rule. Instead, Minister of Economic Affairs Hubert Aiwanger (Free Voters) is planning the energy future as follows: "With gas power and combined heat and power generation, we are guaranteeing security of supply for Bavaria as an industrial location." That's right! The logical next step would be to gradually substitute natural gas with synthetic gas from wind or solar... the long-term storage facilities in the gas grid and caverns are already available at no additional cost to consumers.

The environment is obviously not (yet) on the ministers' minds...

Future energy team Gammel

More News

Gammel-Inside

Our new homepage is online!

Read more
18.08.2025
Press

FUTURE-proof concepts against the energy shock in milk and cheese production

Read more
06.08.2025
Gammel-Inside

Congratulations, dear Tom!

Read more
31.07.2025
Experience and innovation
in every project. *
Contact
Gammel Engineering GmbH
An den Sandwellen 114
93326 Abensberg
Office Cham
Gewerbepark Chammünster Nord 3
93413 Cham

Careers at Gammel Engineering